The problem with the U.S. education system

The public-school system in America is failing for two very basic reasons. One, they’re public. OK, for the moment we can’t help that. But two, they’re a monopoly – and that can be helped.

My understanding is that public education in many European countries is far superior to American public education (at least in terms of academics, if not values) for the simple reason that funding is attached to the child, not the school. The child’s parents decide where to send their kid – religious, secular or government-run schools – and academic institutions must therefore compete to attract students.

But in the U.S., funding is attached to the schools, who can then give a virtual middle finger to parents whenever they complain about what and how their children are taught. (And educators wonder why homeschooling has blossomed in the last decade.) Public schools can be unresponsive and uncaring to parental demands because they know parents have no choice but to send their children to school, unless parents make extreme sacrifices to send their children to private, church or home schools. Most parents can’t afford the time or money to take advantage of these options, so their kids become trapped in a system which is designed to do little more than turn them into drones of the state.

Parents are even prosecuted if they’re “caught” in the crime of sending their children to a different school district that may offer higher standards and better academics. This national desire to obtain the best available education for one’s children can and does affect household income, time management and even home purchases. In fact, one of the reasons behind the rising housing market in the early part of this decade was a desperate desire for parents to buy homes in good school districts, where the value of those homes skyrocketed. (I think it’s a safe assumption that homes in rotten school districts aren’t nearly as valuable.)

We have poured untold billions of dollars down the rat hole of government education and have accomplished far less than the one-room classes of Laura’s day. Of course in the “little schoolroom on the prairie,” the educators worked for the local community, and the teachers had to teach what the parents expected or they’d be fired. Like private enterprise, the product (education) had to meet the expectations of the customers (parents).

But when “education” becomes a powerful lobbying group and teachers become government employees, the status quo is viciously defended and other educational alternatives are belittled and sometimes even outlawed. (Source: WND)

Go to the source for an interesting and excellent analysis of why the public education system gets a big, fat “F”. Of course the teachers’ union and their government pals will continue to claim it’s all about the children.

Powered by ScribeFire.

Enhanced by Zemanta

Share

Advertisements

One thought on “The problem with the U.S. education system

  1. School for Boston Public School teachers starts on Tuesday. The kids come back Wednesday. Three chairs at a table, eight tables, I have 24 seats in my classroom. The class size limit in Boston is 31 per class.

    I downloaded my class lists and I see the following:

    Math elective, period 3: 37 students
    Algebra 2, period 4: 33 students
    Algebra 2, period 5: 25 students
    Algebra 2, period 6: 24 students

    By my schedule, you can see I’m a math teacher. As hard as calculus was, I got through it. I even got through a java programming class that sucked 15 pounds out of my body. But I just can’t seem to do the following proble

    37 students + 24 seats + class size limitation of 31 = success. Solve for HOW.

    I appreciate any and all suggestions on how to pull this one off. These are the kinds of things people forget about us teachers. We “get summers off”, we “only work 6 hours a day”, we “have tons of vacations”, we are “failing our kids”. But no one ever comments on how we’re sometimes set up to fail before we even begin.

    I’m scared for Wednesday, not because I don’t think I can teach 37 kids at a time but because I don’t know how to choose who gets a seat and who sits on the floor.

Comments are closed.