It’s time to take aim at claims being made regarding Social Security.
U.S. Representative Steve Kagen’s (D-8th District) Social Security ad claims that his Republican opponent, Reid Ribble, wants to “…phase out Social Security, forcing Wisconsin’s seniors to fend for themselves”. It goes on to use a partial-sentence quote from Ribble made at a candidate forum: “…(S)omehow we have to establish a phase out of the current Social Security system…”.
That partial-sentence quote came from a candidate forum hosted by the Fox Valley Initiative on 11/3/2009, and does not include either the end of that sentence or the preceding sentence. The parts that were omitted by the Kagen campaign prove the lie. The fuller quote, taken from the Appleton Post-Crescent taping of the forum, with Ribble’s answer beginning at the 1:33:00 mark and the question being answered at the 1:30:40 mark, is, “There’s been a promise made and for those of you that are in their retirement years, you lived and planned your life based on a promise by your government. And so somehow we have to establish a phase out of the current Social Security system to a new system, and that will have to happen over time.”
See Congressman Kagen even those outside the 8th Congressional District are on to your shenanigans.
Powered by ScribeFire.
Related articles by Zemanta
- Fact-Checking Reid Ribble on Social Security (rhymeswithclown.blogspot.com)
- Social Security: Ribble’s real position (brvanlanen.wordpress.com)
- Kagen dusting off the old playbook (brvanlanen.wordpress.com)